Back Pain

Spinal Decompression for Back Pain: Non-Surgical vs Surgery

The traction table and the operation are very different things. Here is how each works, what the research says and what to try first.

By Sophie BrownUpdated Oct 9, 20265 min read

“Spinal decompression” is used for two very different things. One is non-surgical decompression, a motorised traction table offered by some chiropractors and clinics, often as an expensive package of sessions. The other is decompression surgery, an operation that frees trapped nerves in the spine. They have very different evidence behind them, and knowing which is which can save you money and help you choose the right treatment for your back pain.

Quick answer: Spinal decompression means two different treatments. Non-surgical spinal decompression uses a motorised traction table, and research and guidelines show little or no benefit for back pain or sciatica. Decompression surgery, such as a laminectomy or discectomy, removes what is pressing on a nerve and can help carefully selected people with severe or worsening symptoms. For most back pain, staying active and exercise-based physiotherapy are the best place to start.

What Does “Compression” Mean in the Spine?

The spinal cord and the nerves branching off it run through openings in the vertebrae. Pressure on these nerves is what doctors usually mean by compression. Common causes include:

  • A herniated (slipped) disc, where the soft centre of a disc bulges out and presses on a nerve root
  • Spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the spinal canal, usually from age-related wear, thickened ligaments and bone spurs
  • Degenerative disc disease, where discs lose height and the spaces for nerves shrink
  • Spondylolisthesis, where one vertebra slips forward over another
  • Less commonly, injuries, tumours or infections
Doctor examining a patient with neck and spine pain

Symptoms of Nerve Compression

  • Back or neck pain
  • Pain that shoots down a leg (sciatica) or an arm
  • Numbness, tingling or pins and needles
  • Weakness in a leg, foot, arm or hand
  • With spinal stenosis, leg pain or heaviness when walking that eases when you sit or bend forward
Go to an emergency department if back pain comes with numbness around your genitals or buttocks, new trouble controlling your bladder or bowels, or weakness in both legs. These can be signs of cauda equina syndrome, which needs urgent surgery.

Non-Surgical Spinal Decompression

Non-surgical spinal decompression is a form of motorised traction. You lie on a computer-controlled table with a harness around your hips and chest. The table gently pulls and relaxes in cycles, aiming to stretch the spine, create negative pressure inside the discs and take pressure off nerves. Sessions last around 30 to 45 minutes and are usually sold as a course of many visits.

Does spinal decompression work?

The evidence is weak. A Cochrane review of traction for low back pain, with or without sciatica, found that traction alone or with other treatments has little or no effect on pain, function or return to work. The UK’s NICE guideline on low back pain and sciatica advises against offering traction.

Clinics often show impressive testimonials, and some people do feel better during a course of treatment. But back pain frequently improves on its own over weeks, which makes it hard to know whether the table caused the change. The treatment is generally low risk, but it can be costly and is often not covered by insurance.

Spinal Decompression Surgery

Surgical spinal decompression removes whatever is pressing on the nerves. According to the NHS, it is usually considered when non-surgical treatments have not helped and symptoms are severe or getting worse. Common procedures include:

  • Laminectomy: removing part of the bony arch of a vertebra (the lamina) to widen the spinal canal, often for spinal stenosis.
  • Discectomy: removing the part of a herniated disc that presses on a nerve.
  • Foraminotomy: widening the opening where a nerve root leaves the spine.
  • Spinal fusion is sometimes added if the spine needs extra stability.

Surgery is usually better at relieving leg pain from a trapped nerve than back pain itself. Most people are up and walking within a day or two, return to light activity within a few weeks, and recover more fully over several months.

Doctor holding a spine model to explain decompression surgery

Risks of spinal decompression surgery

  • Infection and bleeding
  • Blood clots in the legs
  • A tear in the membrane around the nerves (dural tear), which can cause a leak of spinal fluid
  • Nerve damage, which can rarely cause numbness or weakness
  • Symptoms not improving, or returning later
  • Risks of general anaesthesia

What Usually Helps First

For most back pain, including sciatica, guidelines recommend starting with:

For nerve pain down the leg, see our guide to what actually helps sciatica. If symptoms persist, a doctor may suggest steroid injections or refer you to a spine specialist to discuss surgery.

Physiotherapist treating a patient with back and leg pain

If you are weighing up self-adjustment or a chiropractor, read how to crack your back and neck safely.

FAQ

Is non-surgical spinal decompression worth it?

The research does not show clear benefits over other treatments, and major guidelines do not recommend traction. Exercise-based physiotherapy has much stronger evidence and is often cheaper.

Is spinal decompression safe?

Non-surgical spinal decompression is generally low risk, though it may not suit people with osteoporosis, fractures, tumours, spinal implants or during pregnancy. Surgery carries the usual risks of an operation, which your surgeon will discuss with you.

How long is recovery after decompression surgery?

Many people go home within a few days and return to desk work within a few weeks. Heavier work and sport may take longer, and full recovery can take several months.

Can a herniated disc heal without surgery?

Yes. Many herniated discs shrink and symptoms improve within weeks to months with time, activity and physiotherapy.

The Bottom Line

Non-surgical spinal decompression is a traction table treatment with little evidence that it works better than other approaches, so think carefully before paying for a long package. Spinal decompression surgery is a proven option for carefully selected people with trapped nerves and severe symptoms that have not improved. For most back pain, staying active and a good exercise programme remain the best starting point. Explore more in our back and neck pain hub.

This article is for general information and is not a substitute for advice from your doctor.

Sources

Medical disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not a substitute for advice, diagnosis or treatment from a qualified health professional. If your symptoms are severe, sudden or getting worse, contact a doctor or emergency services.

Written by

Sophie Brown

Health writer179 articlesSources linked

Sophie Brown writes the health and wellness guides on Better Life Carez, covering skin care, weight loss and nutrition, back and neck pain, women's health and everyday wellbeing. She is not a doctor or licensed health professional, and the articles on this site are not medically reviewed. Where an article relies on a study or a health organization's guidance, it links to that source so you can check it yourself. Her guides are for general information and are not a substitute for advice from your own doctor.

Part of our health guide

Back and Neck Pain

Browse every related article on this topic in one place.

Explore the guide

Keep reading

Comments are closed.